My brother has asked me for a loan of 15 lakhs to invest in his business, promising a 10% annual return, while I currently have this amount invested in fixed deposits earning a safe 7% return. While the higher return sounds attractive, I'm concerned about the risks involved, the potential strain on our relationship if things go wrong, the lack of liquidity compared to FDs, and the need for proper legal safeguards. Given these financial and emotional factors, should I lend him the money or politely decline and stick with the safety of my existing investment?
Ans: Your question shows strong financial awareness and emotional maturity. You are thinking not just about returns, but also risks, liquidity, and relationships. That is smart and responsible.
Let’s look at this from a full 360-degree angle — not just money, but also family, safety, and peace of mind.
Understanding the Proposal
Your brother wants a loan of Rs. 15 lakhs.
He is promising a 10% annual return.
Currently, this money is in FDs giving you 7%.
The interest difference is 3%. That is Rs. 45,000 per year extra.
But the extra return comes with higher risk.
FD returns are guaranteed and safe.
Business returns are not guaranteed.
If his business struggles, your money is not safe.
If he fails to repay, relationship damage is possible.
Key Financial Risks You Must Consider
No guarantee: A verbal promise of 10% return is not binding.
No collateral: Business loans without security carry high risk.
Illiquidity: You lose flexibility. FDs can be broken. Business money is locked.
Opportunity cost: If you need money urgently, it may not come back in time.
No regulation: FDs are regulated by RBI. Business lending is private and unregulated.
Emotional and Relationship Risk
If business fails, the loss will not just be money.
You may lose family peace.
It may create long-term emotional stress.
Money between siblings should never become a barrier.
Lending money may feel like helping now.
But repayment failure may feel like betrayal later.
Can You Consider a Middle Path?
If you still wish to support your brother, consider a limited-exposure strategy.
Offer a smaller amount. Maybe Rs. 2 to 5 lakhs only.
Treat it like an investment, not a loan.
Ask for proper legal documentation.
Create a simple written agreement with timelines and repayment terms.
Don’t depend on this money for your major goals.
Don’t lend entire Rs. 15 lakhs. Keep your FDs safe.
See how the business performs over 1–2 years.
If all goes well, you can revisit later.
If You Choose to Decline
Declining is not wrong. You are protecting your financial base.
You can politely explain that your current financial goals are fixed.
Say your investments are meant for your son's education or your retirement.
Offer him non-financial help if possible — like guidance, contacts, or referrals.
You can even say: “I want to help you, but can’t risk my core goals.”
Maintain warmth. Make it clear it’s not personal.
Legal Safeguards (If You Decide to Lend)
If you go ahead, then take proper precautions.
Create a loan agreement with amount, tenure, return, and repayment plan.
Get it signed on stamp paper.
Mention the 10% return and repayment schedule.
Have two witnesses sign it.
Mention what happens in case of delay or default.
Consult a lawyer for proper format.
Even family loans need documentation.
Keep all communication in writing.
Final Insights
Money between relatives is always sensitive.
It is not just about 3% extra return.
It is about trust, emotion, peace, and long-term stability.
Your fixed deposits are safe. They are liquid. They support your retirement plan.
Your brother’s proposal is tempting, but carries high risk.
You must protect your financial future first.
If you wish to help, limit your exposure.
Document everything legally.
Or you can say no politely and preserve the relationship.
Don’t let emotional pressure force a financial decision.
Keep your family bond stronger than money.
Make a decision that gives you financial peace and emotional comfort.
Best Regards,
K. Ramalingam, MBA, CFP,
Chief Financial Planner,
www.holisticinvestment.in
https://www.youtube.com/@HolisticInvestment